The Skinny Website

1. 64 Responses to “Keira Knightley is No Longer Scary Skinny”

2. By mel on Jun 5, 2007 | Reply

   god i wish i had a body like that (:((:((

3. By Lazara on Jun 5, 2007 | Reply

   she is soo beautiful, even though she is too skinny…

4. By just_me on Jun 5, 2007 | Reply

   ^– I wish I had a boyfriend like that

5. By libby on Jun 5, 2007 | Reply

   pretty sure that in real life she’s still ’scary skinny’. i feel we are so desensitized to skinniness in photos and on tv. these pictures still show extreme thinness… her thighs look muscley though, but she is still breast-less. thats probably her normal body type though, but standing next to her shed still be tttttiiiiiny.

6. By Woods on Jun 5, 2007 | Reply

   I adore her outfit.

7. By cat on Jun 5, 2007 | Reply

   i agree with libby. she is pear shaped and even at her skinniest, her legs were never as tiny as her upper half. also, love the shoes, hate her dress.

8. By tyghda on Jun 5, 2007 | Reply

   She’s still scary skinny but she always had big legs compare to her upper bode, but look at her stick waists! That’s shows you how much the dress can change it all.

9. By Sacharomyces cerevisiae on Jun 5, 2007 | Reply

   wow a happy pair of matching bohos. even their flip flops are the same. And he borrowed her “I am not a plastic bag” also-how sweet! washboard t*ts btw

10. By Sacharomyces cerevisiae on Jun 5, 2007 | Reply

    mel, to put it politely-are you out of your mind girl?????

11. By Poppet on Jun 5, 2007 | Reply

    Think Kiera was right in filing that law suite - she only looked skinny after pirates becasue of all the intense action scenes…. she is not an anorexic and it must have been so frustrating for her to be called one…. as soon as she is not working, she relaxes, puts on a bit of weight and looks absolutely stunning again!

12. By Melissa on Jun 5, 2007 | Reply

    I think she looks amazing. She has always been super tiny. I feel like if she even loses the slightest amount of weight then her chest bones are going to show, but I am like that too. She has great legs. And I like her dress. Why on earth is she wearing a fedora? Lol.

13. By Muffy on Jun 5, 2007 | Reply

    It’s sad when people get past the point of perfect and begin to look like little boys. She is definitely a little boy.

    And, I hate when people try to make themselves ugly. That dress and hat are HORRIBLE!!!!!!!

14. By skinny minnie on Jun 5, 2007 | Reply

    im not convinced shes not still too thin- they had to use a leg double in the new pirates film at the end with orlando bloom, prob cos her legs were like bloody toothpicks!!

15. By Kittah on Jun 5, 2007 | Reply

    I kinda like that dress but……are those man-capris?!

16. By megan on Jun 5, 2007 | Reply

    I have to agree with libby. If you were friends with her in real life, you would probably think she WAS a little scary skinny. People may complain about how our perception of what is “too big” is changing and vanity sizing, which may be true….but at the same time, Hollywood is ruining our perception of what is “too skinny”. We think because a star’s ribcage and collarbone aren’t sharp enough to hurt someone yet, they are still not too thin. Someone cn be underweight or too thin and not have every bone on their body showing.

    That being said, I don’t think she has an eating disorder, I do think it’s natural. I just think it’s funny what people’s ideas of too thin are.

17. By Lafta on Jun 5, 2007 | Reply

    I just love her for some reason!!!!! From Bend It Like Beckham to Pirates 3. I know there are no “naturally thin” people in Hollywood, but I really think she is. She has a boyish figure, and I think it suits her. I would luv, luv, luv, to meet her. Her and President Carter, lol!!!

18. By Elle on Jun 5, 2007 | Reply

    She is still very thin but I think she looks great! I love the style of that dress!

19. By Mylo on Jun 5, 2007 | Reply

    she doesnt know how to combine her (nice) clothes
    Shoes with dress with bag with hat
    iehww so obviously wrong!

20. By brandy alexander on Jun 5, 2007 | Reply

    I like what she is wearing.

    She is pear shaped, so her legs have really never been scary skinny. Her upper body is what gets so freakishly thin.

    I think she looks great.

21. By Bgirl on Jun 5, 2007 | Reply

    love her Issa dress!

    she is thin but her figure is otherwise nothing special. nothing womanly about her.

22. By junkenstein on Jun 5, 2007 | Reply

    I really hate her, but the dress is very cute.
    I don’t think she’s much bigger than the ones that are labeled as scary-skinny. And as it was pointed out, in real life she’s probably one of them.

23. By Kimmy on Jun 5, 2007 | Reply

    No, her legs as far as we can see in this picture don’t look scary skinny but see her arms in the first picture. I mean the’re so small I even need glasses to look for ‘em

24. By An on Jun 5, 2007 | Reply

    She’s always been thin, why should we expect her to be anything except thin? she’s young and probably won’t put any weight anytime soon. I think we’re all used to fat people- so skinny people are looked at as being ‘too thin.’

25. By weeee on Jun 5, 2007 | Reply

    i think i have a girl crush. lol. I think she looks great. yes- she’s skinny but she’s always played roles of strong women: potc, bend it like beckham, king arthur, etc. and in all of the’s movies she’s proved to look very fit.

26. By asiangirl on Jun 5, 2007 | Reply

    I’d say — welcome to the human world. But why is she always wearing weird clothes? The dress is cute but why the hat? Why those sandals?

27. By Ellie on Jun 5, 2007 | Reply

    Her body is very boyish. I don’t think she’s anorexic or anything, but she has no shape to her. She is still scary skinny yes. It’s the dress that masks it. Not only the pattern, but the shape of the dress. Even so, she’s still looks very thin in these pictures, and underneath she is still scary skinny. It’s not normal to see a backbone and rib bones. Sad that she says she wants to gain weight but can’t.

28. By girlie girl on Jun 5, 2007 | Reply

    She still is nasty…and what is with her dress?! LOL She needs a serious makeover, yuck!

29. By Karma on Jun 5, 2007 | Reply

    She’s still tiny. Look at her waist!!
    This girl doesn’t do it for me. I couldn’t stand her in The Jacket. Talk about over-acting!!

30. By maddie on Jun 5, 2007 | Reply

    what the heck r u talking about? shes still a stick. she looks unhealthy.

31. By LaLa on Jun 5, 2007 | Reply

    Knightley’s pear shaped, but she’s fit so she doesn’t look very disproportionate as pear shaped people tend to be.

32. By hez on Jun 5, 2007 | Reply

    I love that dress and want her legs. But is that the same boyfriend as before? He looks less Orlando Bloom-y than regular.

33. By lambman on Jun 5, 2007 | Reply

    she would be so beautiful if she just fixed her underbite. But will still just be a less gorgeous, less talented Natalie Portman knock off.

34. By li on Jun 5, 2007 | Reply

    Issa? Her dress is Celia Birtwell for Topshop!

35. By Persephone on Jun 5, 2007 | Reply

    I love that dress. I could do without the rest of the outfit. I am not sure if she has gained or not. I never thought she was too thin.

36. By SuperModelSuzie on Jun 5, 2007 | Reply

    The dress fits her well. And she must have amazing legs for them to look that good in flats!

37. By peach on Jun 5, 2007 | Reply

    keiras always been skinny and toned - even when she first appeared in The Hole
    Personally i never understood the fuss!!
    she does like to pout though!

38. By nwisbest on Jun 5, 2007 | Reply

    Even if she gained weight, it wouldn’t go to her boobs. Just accept it and lay off. She’s actually more muscular than I originally thought and she looks really healthy. Good legs too.

39. By Lily Munster on Jun 5, 2007 | Reply

    How do these pictures prove she’s not “scary skinny”? Is it in her legs? I agree her legs seem to be normal, but does anyone see how narrow she is in her upper body?

    I personally believe that yes, she is skinny, but the way her body is built so long and lean exagerrates it.

40. By julia on Jun 5, 2007 | Reply

    to me…keira only gained some weight around her “Domino” times, however, before that and after that she is the SAME size…the pics from the premier of POTC (the first one) are NO different than the pics from the beach in Hawaii (and those ones everyone called scary skinny)….

    she’s the same over the last few years…i duno, thats my opinion…

    the only difference is that her fashion sense is getting progressively worse….isnt she getting a buttload of free Chanel crap now that she’s repping their perfume?? I see her wearing the purses, perhaps, she should pick up some clothes too…just sayin’…

41. By Nicolette on Jun 5, 2007 | Reply

    Hm…I don’t know, she’s pretty darn scrawny to me.

42. By elise on Jun 6, 2007 | Reply

    Her cheeks are still sunken and the legs are still thin. I can’t see a gain.

43. By mimi on Jun 6, 2007 | Reply

    I think the only reason some people called her scary skinny is her disproportinate body (too skinny upper part) and her gaunt face. But some people are just that way - they have naturally small waists, no boobs and even ribs sticking out because of the skinniness of their upper part and at the same time their bottoms may be very heavy. Keira is definitely pear shaped - her hips and thighs look pretty normal, it’s the upper body that makes her look so skinny. But I think it’s just her physique, as I said some people are naturally like that, it isn’t a result from starving. Other than that I think she really has put on some pounds maybe 5-7. And of course they showed in her thight area.

44. By Fliss on Jun 6, 2007 | Reply

    She could definitley do with a few pounds but I think she is one of these naturally skinny girls.

45. By Prinzz on Jun 6, 2007 | Reply

    To all the people who were wondering : yes, it’s the same boyfriend. Rupert went blond.

46. By coffeecup on Jun 6, 2007 | Reply

    Damn sexy outfit!!! Ok ppl why isnt laetitia casta on this site??????? Pleeeez feature her…i wanna know her diet and workout. She has the perfect body ever.

47. By missy on Jun 6, 2007 | Reply

    She still looks scary to me. That dress creates the illusion of curves. She WASNT always this thin. Remember Bend it Like Beckham? she was thin but more toned and not so bony. In person she must look like a pencil. She needs to gain a good 10-15lbs..

48. By Sally on Jun 7, 2007 | Reply

    not scary skinny? look at how gaunt her face is

49. By mimi on Jun 7, 2007 | Reply

    people don’t you understand if she gains a “good” 5-10 lbs they will go straight to her bottom, her face will still be gaunt and her upper body will still be awfully bony. that’s just her physique. and in this way she will look even more disproportional. she’s just right now.

50. By mimi on Jun 7, 2007 | Reply

    i meant she’s fine how she’s just right now

51. By raquelle on Jun 7, 2007 | Reply

    i LOVE this girl’s style. her legs look healthy skinny but her face and waist still look to thin. that’s probably because of her being pear shaped

52. By strawberry curls on Jun 8, 2007 | Reply

    I really have to say that Kiera is my absolute favorite actress. She’s so beautiful. I really don’t want her to quit acting.

    she looks perfect.

53. By Line on Jun 9, 2007 | Reply

    aw…her boyfriend looks cute, i want someone with hair like that…

54. By UberOrange on Jun 13, 2007 | Reply

    I love Kiera Knightly, she’s so talented and beautiful and is a naturally thin girl. ok there was that whole scandel with the gold dress but look at her now? why dwell on the past?

55. By omfg girl on Jun 13, 2007 | Reply

    she needs to eat and get somekinda sense of style!

56. By Michelle on Jun 15, 2007 | Reply

    Everytime pictures apear that show her legs, people assume she’s gained weight. Really, you should all take notice, its quite funny. Fact is, that she’s still as skinny as before, its just that her legs arent as skinny as her upperbody, so when they come to display she apears to have gained weight.

57. By Cassie on Jun 15, 2007 | Reply

    umm shes n0t too skinny she’s f i n e.

58. By preeya on Jun 18, 2007 | Reply

    okay there is no doubt that the dress is flaterring toher figure. but she is still really thin.

59. By SoCal girl on Jun 22, 2007 | Reply

    She has a beautiful face and GREAT legs.

    I think she is extremely skinny though…but she probably is naturally skinny…

    She looks good tall and lanky.

60. By someone on Jun 26, 2007 | Reply

    NATURALLY SKINNY !!!

    that’s right

    u ppl dont get it do you=???

    THERE ARE SOME WHO ARE BORN THIN…

    It’s kinda discriminating to call someone like her ” ANOREXIC ” or BULIMIC..

    so dumb really..

61. By sinéad on Jul 24, 2007 | Reply

    i’d like that dress, that body and face please, thanks;)hehe, i love her! shes fabulous, i wish she didnt get so much stick for being skinny, she was always skinny, you should see her in Bend It Like Beckham, she has the body of a little boy, shes really just naturally skinny, but she has an amasing face, and i have a feeling shes one of the nicest most down-to-earth celebs in hollywood, she always comes across that way in interviews anyways,

62. By Sasha on Jul 26, 2007 | Reply

    Her underbite makes her jaw more defined, which could be good, but for her case, it makes her look like she’s forcing her mouth to be that way and it looks absolutely disgusting. If she had a bit more flesh, she’d look a lot more agreeable to the eyes. Something about her here turns me off. She looks like she hasn’t had a good night’s rest for a month.

63. By texas on Aug 6, 2007 | Reply

    skinney bitch

64. By kate` on Aug 8, 2007 | Reply

    this girl is verrry skinny but not TOO skinny… don’t you understand that celebs buy cocaine to keep their weight down? i mean that’s taking the easy way out!

    she is perfect weight though i love her she’s gorgeous!

65. By Nikki on Aug 11, 2007 | Reply

    I’m pretty sure that just because she’s not overweight or deathly obese like 60% of North Americans does NOT mean she’s “scary skinny”. She looks healthy to me, and just because she has no boobs does not make her anorexic.

**Please read the rules, located here, before making a comment! If you choose to comment, you are agreeing to the rules. ALSO Please Note: Your comment may take a few moments to show up. Please do not submit it more than once! Thank you!**