Sienna Miller Defends Keira Knightley Over Anorexia Claims
It appears that Keira Knightley’s anorexia scandal isn’t quite over yet. Sienna Miller has decided to speak up and defend her.
Sienna claims that her and Keira have worked together on movie sets and are good friends. Most importantly, however, she says that Keira definitely isn’t anorexic. She actually eats “like a pig” and asks for second helpings.
“She eats like a horse. She always asks for seconds and loves her apple crumble. There’s no way she has an eating problem,” Contact-music quoted her as saying.
“She is a really good friend of mine, she is a wonderful girl. Eats like a pig for everyone out there who calls her anorexic,” she added.
I don’t doubt it. Recent photos have suggested that Keira is no longer scary-skinny.
88 Responses to “Sienna Miller Defends Keira Knightley Over Anorexia Claims”
By Hillie on Jun 14, 2007 | Reply
This is absolutely the most hideous picture of Sienna Miller ever!! Looking like that, I’m sure Keira would rather she kept her mouth shut!
By dizzy on Jun 14, 2007 | Reply
what the hell is she wearing in tht pikki?!?!
By none on Jun 14, 2007 | Reply
ugh, i don’t believe it. or maybe i just don’t want to believe girls THAT thin can actually eat generous portions of anything they like. i have to cut calories dramatically just to keep my weight at the lower end of my healthy weight range, and she certainly looks a little underweight.
By Karma on Jun 14, 2007 | Reply
I don’t know if Sienna needed to go as far as to say that Keira “eats like a pig” to prove her point. Now the tabloids might turn around and say she’s binging and purging (you never know what they’re going to say next). It’s just rude anyway. Let the girl have seconds and a little bit of dessert- that doesn’t make her a pig.
I don’t know why everyone is still on Keira’s case- it’s not like she was heavy and then dropped down to 100 pounds. She’s always been thin. Hollywood needs to come up with some new stories it seems…
By thinista on Jun 14, 2007 | Reply
Kiera’s a coke whore and that’s how she stays thin. Stimulants speed up your metabolism - the fact that many many actresses in the entertianment industry use drugs to keep their weight down is the dirty little secret that no-one ever mentions. Sienna would know full well that her drug use helps Kiera to stay slim while she ‘eats like a pig’
By Benjie McMurray on Jun 14, 2007 | Reply
Cripes, what in God’s name is she wearing?
About Kiera, who gives an eff? Chick was born skinny and will always be skinny, unless someone force feeds her Krispy Kremes everyday.
By V on Jun 14, 2007 | Reply
Uh..anybody ever heard of bulimia?!!
You can eat like a pig, and be that thin, if you are bulimic!!
I am not saying she is, maybe she has a great metabolism..but hey, anorexia isn’t the only eating disorder on earth.
By SuperModelSuzie on Jun 14, 2007 | Reply
Skinny girls don’t eat like pigs. PERIOD! Anyone who says they do is LYING!!!
By SuperModelSuzie on Jun 14, 2007 | Reply
Unless of course they’re bullimic…
By DaveW on Jun 14, 2007 | Reply
Wow, actresses look so glamorous nowadays, LOL. Ava Gardner Lauren Bacall and Marilyn Monroe wouldn’t have got out of bed looking like that, much less walked down the street.
By Tracy on Jun 14, 2007 | Reply
There is almost no doubt in my mind that Keira Knightley has an eating disorder. It is most likely anorexia- she isn’t just thin, it’s unnatural- her bones stick out everywhere, especially on her shoulders and chest. I love her to death and I think she’s ridiculously beautiful, but she definately has some form of anorexia.
By asiangirl on Jun 14, 2007 | Reply
Sienna Miller looks very untoned in this picture, although it could be the hideous dress she’s wearing. Why oh why do celebrities choose clothes that do not look good on them?
By Scarlet on Jun 14, 2007 | Reply
i think its bull- keira has not got an eating disorder - she is not anorexic, she is not bulimic! she is naturally skinny - watch her early movies - shes tiny then too. christ!
By Emi on Jun 14, 2007 | Reply
yea she eats like that when she’s binging.
I have an ED so I know what it’s like!
By stef on Jun 14, 2007 | Reply
sienna looks like she is packing on the pounds
By Yo on Jun 14, 2007 | Reply
No SupersizeModel- you are wrong. All through college in into my mid twenties I remained very small but also binged regularly ( I smoked a lot of pot) and drank a lot too. I did happen to work out on a consistant basis though. Point is- everyone is different. You can’t say skinny people don’t eat. Some of them have fast metabolisms. Some of them work out and therefore compensate for the calories. I am living proof as are tons of women.
By Yo on Jun 14, 2007 | Reply
And Emi, I doubt she “binges” in front of people. Most of us that have eating disorders do it in hiding. Sienna’s statement was just far fetched.
By Confused on Jun 14, 2007 | Reply
Dear Yo,
Please pick one:
“Some of them work out and therefore compensate for the calories. I am living proof as are tons of women.”
“I doubt she “binges” in front of people. Most of us that have eating disorders do it in hiding.”
Love,
Confused.
By lulabell on Jun 14, 2007 | Reply
when you said supersizemodel, did you actually mean supermodelsuzie??!!
freudian slip perhaps?!
By Jesska on Jun 14, 2007 | Reply
OMG would you give the girl a break! She has always been thin and doesn’t seem to have an eating disorder. Why is it that every thin girl is slammed for having a coke habit .. I mean where is your proof???Anyway I think this constant speculation and scrutiny over her weight surely does not help if she was anorexic. I think that this obsession people have over weight is pretty sick and pathetic.
By Tracy on Jun 14, 2007 | Reply
Hahaha. Just because she was thin at the start of her career means she doesn’t have an eating disorder? Good job using your brains! She was probably anorexic THEN TOO.
By kiki on Jun 14, 2007 | Reply
Kiera is incredibly iritating, self depreciating and dull.
She may be thin, but she is big boned/framed.
She blatantly has ‘eating issues’ as if she isnt discussing her own weight/figure/dislike of parts of body, she is expressing envy of someone else’s figure. usually someone not too attractive.
Either that or she is one of those girls who criticises herself and insincerely flatters ugly people to make herself feel special!
By suzy on Jun 14, 2007 | Reply
Unfortunate choice of words… who wants to be known for eating like a pig? A horse, maybe? In Keira’s case a skinny little horse. She must eats something, but I doubt it’s much or often. If she ate a lot and worked it off, she’d have muscles. So… that leaves: fast metabolism, coke habit or eating disorder. Or some happy combination…
Is one of the hanger-ribbon things hanging out of the front of Sienna’s dress?
By Jesska on Jun 14, 2007 | Reply
Tracy - I am not saying she doesn’t have an eating disorder …tbh I do not think that anyone really knows whether she does or not. I mean do you know her personally?? no I thought not. I just think that this kind of constant criticism over her weight must be quite distressing either way.
By Ellie on Jun 14, 2007 | Reply
First, I couldn’t really care less if Keira Knightley has an eating disorder or not. Either way, her body is not desirable in my eyes. Second, I was extremely thin at one point (growth spurt) and I couldn’t eat much. I got full very quickly. It is unnatural for Keira to look the way she does. If it were natural and a healthy weight for her frame, then she would not have bones poking through her skin. If she didn’t have some sort of problem, then her chest bones wouldn’t be visible, her hip bones, or her backbone. That is not natural no matter what she says. Sure she could have a fast metabolism, but she still would not look the way she does.
By Yo on Jun 14, 2007 | Reply
Confused- not sure what you need clarification on. My first statement was in response to how skinny women can eat like pigs.
In my twenties, LIKE I SAID, I was very thin, worked out and binged regularly (or ate like a pig sometimes like Keira apparently does).
I am now 31 with an eating disorder. Anything else I can help you with??
By Desiree on Jun 14, 2007 | Reply
Just because certain bones poke out does not indicate any kind of eating disorder. All people are built differently- different people store fat in different areas. I don’t have an eating disorder, but I have always been really bony in my chest, back, and hipbones. I carry weight in my legs, which never really change size if I lose weight. And even though you can see the bones in my upper chest, I still am not flat chested.
By Tracy on Jun 14, 2007 | Reply
Ellie, I agree with you completely, and you are right. No matter how “naturally thin” you are, you don’t look like that unless you have an eating disorder.
By lambman on Jun 14, 2007 | Reply
ugh Sienna, that’s my only reaction to anything she says, does or wears anymore.
though since its this site I’ll throw in that she looks to have gained 10 pounds, not that it is a bad thing were she dressed better I’d say its an improvement
By Anonymous Realist on Jun 14, 2007 | Reply
But thinista, the major impact of such stimulants is a reduction in appetite.
What kind of f*cked up world are we living in that a “friend” describing you as “eating like a pig” and a “horse” is supposed to be complimentary?
By Nicolette on Jun 14, 2007 | Reply
Wow these people are ALL idiots.
Why would u call her a pig if your defending her? That’s nice.
By thinista on Jun 14, 2007 | Reply
True Anonymous Realist, I guess I meant that she would appear to eat a lot say, on set, but go out later and ‘party’ it all off. After a binge of many hours, when the drug has worn off, one can wake up starving. Of course , I may be wrong and she may be entirely blameless.
By Persephone on Jun 14, 2007 | Reply
Don’t know or don’t care if she has an eating disorder or not. I have never thought she was scary skinny.
Everyone is different. SOme skinny people could very well eat like pigs.
As far as having an eating disorder and binging in front of people, I always binged in front of people so that they thought that I ate. Once again, everyone is different.
By Ellie on Jun 14, 2007 | Reply
Bones can stick out to some degree. That can be considered normal depending on a persons bone structure. But ALL of her bones stick out. That is very unnatural. You can tell from her bone structure that she should have at least another 10 pounds on her frame to be within a normal weight. She doesn’t have that extra weight. Not only that, but when seeing her in a bikini (she doesn’t have a great body either because of her skinny state) she appears as though she works out excessively as well. So put two and two together. Very skinny with bones protruding as well as a lot of muscle tone on an already emaciated frame signifies an eating disorder. Obviously she wasn’t always as thin as she is. Even though still extremely thin, in Bend it like Beckham she had more weight on her frame. Where did that go to? *cough* probably down the toilet. Excessive exercise (which would explain the body of a small boy) is also a disorder. If she eats so much and stays so extremely tiny, one has to wonder what’s really going on. Is it a fast metabolism? I doubt it considering her bone structure, or is it some sort of body issue such as anorexia, bulimia, drinking, drugs, or excessive exercise?
By micha on Jun 14, 2007 | Reply
I heart keira - i’d think she’d be a fun friend and after having followed articles and interviews with her, i’m convinced that she’s content with herself, will eat what she wants and do what she wants. she’s admitted to not liking her chest, but she didn’t go off the shallow end and get implants (yet). she’s pear-shaped and though she’s a whole person skinnier than me, I take comfort in my pear-shapedness too because she hasn’t altered her legs with liposection. i heart keira because she is how she was made, and she doesn’t strive to fit in with young hollywood, especially when she’s with her boyfriend and in england all the time.
By micha on Jun 14, 2007 | Reply
also, someone please explain how a person can survive the physical training and sports practice from Bend It like Beckham, Pirates and King Arthur, with an eating disorder.
By anne on Jun 14, 2007 | Reply
Thats Bull. Ive known girls with full blown anorexia who could ran marathons. Girls who would work out 6-8 hours a day and only eating an apple.
By anne on Jun 14, 2007 | Reply
sorry a bit to tired. it should have said: who ran marathons.
And by the way, she isnt scary skinny in bend it like beckham, thats something she became when conforming in hollywood style
By Cloo on Jun 14, 2007 | Reply
Who asked her? Just when everyone was forgetting about rumous on Keira, she has to open her mouth to defend her. Yeesh. To make people starting sticking their nose in Keira’s business again.
By beautyqueen18 on Jun 14, 2007 | Reply
I don’t know whether or not she has an eating disorder. Doesn’t everyone in Hollywood have them? I would agree that she was anorexic or bulemic if she was ever fat. The fact is Kiera has never been anything other than thin. SuperModelSuzie, I am one of those girls that can eat whatever they want and not gain weight. In fact, I used to have to take supplements to help me gain weight! I was miserable. I looked extremely unhealthy and I would get so pissed when people would accuse me of having an eating disorder! There are girls that really do have fast metabolisms. It’s just hard to determine who has a fast metabolism, all thin girls want to claim that they are naturally skinny. Since Keira has always been tiny, this makes me think she might be naturally small.
By Elle on Jun 14, 2007 | Reply
I love Sienna!! She looks good, a little heavier, horrible dress. It’s horrible how the media makes such a big deal out of girl’s problems after they pressure them to be so small in the first place
By MMH on Jun 14, 2007 | Reply
Whatever………I seriously doubt that Keira ‘pigs out’ like sienna says! There’s NO WAY she can be that skinny and eat a lot! In the first Pirates of the Carribean she was a lot heavier than she is now; and she’s also admitted that ‘anorexia’ runs in her family.
By anonymous on Jun 14, 2007 | Reply
that’s really mean of Sienna Miller to say that she eats like a pig. even if i were really skinny, if someone were to say that about me, i’d feel awful.
By LaLa on Jun 14, 2007 | Reply
I believe the girl!
By catseyesvc on Jun 15, 2007 | Reply
sienna looks TERRIBLE here. my gosh. she needs to lose weight.
By Lazara on Jun 15, 2007 | Reply
She looks great and she doesn’t need to lose weight. Idiot.
Discussing wether someone does or does not have an eating disorder or takes drugs, but insulting anyone who isn’t extremely thin? Yay, great.
By doh on Jun 15, 2007 | Reply
wow you people have no idea.
I’m really skinny, my bones stick out, but my thighs are the same shape as keiras, I eat like a horse, I really do, but I just dont put on weight.
I don’t do coke, I don’t purge.
Maybe I’ll start gaining weight when I get older or something my mom did. She was also super skinny but put on weight when she got older.
Nothing wrong with us, thats just how we’re built.
Why can’t you people just realize that we aren’t all the same it doesn’t have to be a bad thing being superskinny. some of us just look that way.
Just like some people are bigger sizes although they eat healthy and exercise. Nothing weird really.
By ana on Jun 15, 2007 | Reply
I eat as much as I can, maybe it’s not “like a pig”, but it’s everything that I can or want to eat including a lot of chololate, cookies, fattening food… I am 183cm tall (which I believe is 6″ in American measurments) and I weigh 61kg (122 pounds). I do have bones poking in my hip and shoulder area and I have never in my life been anorexic, bulimic or even on a diet. I do try to exercise to gain some muscle and not look like a skeleton. Keira could easily be similar in that respect. If she had some boobs, everybody would be admiring her body. Mine are bigger then hers, so at least I have that going against stupid anorexic comments. People who are naturaly thin are not that difficult to find, I know a few beside myself. Haven’t you people (who instantly accuse skinny people of anorexia) met a normal thin person in your entire lives?!
By Miss M on Jun 15, 2007 | Reply
I don’t think Keira has an eating disorder. She’s always been very very thin. Of course her weight fluctuates as like any other womans. You can’t compare how she looked three or more years ago, she lost that babyfat (even though she didn’t seem to have any) but your body changes.
As for Sienna Miller, I think she felt the need to open her big mouth because she is probably afraid of being out of the press. That dress is vile, the whole woman is vile. She always looks unwashed and unkempt. Fashion icon? My arse!
By Cindy on Jun 15, 2007 | Reply
I’m from Asia, and there are skinny girls in my country who eats alot, almost like a pig, and do not gain an ounce. Usually they are the Chinese, they have super accelerated metabolism. And they DO NOT purge.
Man, I’m jealous when I see them eat.
By peach on Jun 15, 2007 | Reply
I cannot stand Sienna Miller - she only made it as an actress cus of Jude Law… I agree with Miss M - to think of her as a fashion icon is laughable, anyone remember the tummy flattening pants she wore to Factory Girl’s premier?
also anyone else thought that maybe Sienna, who is quite slender, might think a normal portion of food as being alot seeing as she probably doesnt eat alot herself?
By Shelle on Jun 15, 2007 | Reply
In the UK people often joke about eating like a pig. Maybe Keira and Sienna just aren’t so hung up on their weight that they can’t joke about food. Keira Knightley looks fairly tall with a small waist and chest but her legs aren’t scarily skinny. I think she moans about her body because she is a bit pear shaped. She looks amazing, but I can see why she may compare herself to other women and wish she had larger breasts or that her legs were more in proportion to the rest of her figure. I joke that I eat like a pig but all I mean is that I don’t deny myself things, eat good sized meals and snack a lot compared to most of my friends. Having a good appetite and having seconds sometimes yet still being slim does not mean that you have an eating disorder if you eat a balanced diet and are active.
By Lynsey on Jun 15, 2007 | Reply
People who say you cant be skinny and eat a lot are full of shit. Just cos thats not the case for you, doesn’t mean its not the case for other people.
‘Shes bulimic’ Shes anorexic’….blah blah blah. Get over it. The girls naturally thin!
By Fliss on Jun 15, 2007 | Reply
I thought everyone new heaps of starlets did drugs like coke and speed to stay thin? I can’t see what is so wrong this that as it’s their decision and it does not affect anyone else’s health (like smoking). I don’t Keira does tho it’s more the partying LA girls like Lindsay Lohan, Nicole Ritchie and Kate Bosworth
By azuka on Jun 15, 2007 | Reply
Of course, Sienna says “Keira isn’t anorexic” She eats like a horse” … Mmmm… interesting… maybe she isn’t anorexic… she is bulimic… Sad!
By Fliss on Jun 15, 2007 | Reply
and I believe what Ana says 2. Keira looks really tall with a lot of muscle so she prob can eat alot for such a slim person.
Also 61kg is actually 134.5lbs (you would probably need to be hooked up to an IV at 122).
By ana on Jun 15, 2007 | Reply
oops, sorry about the wrong lbs count. I thought it was double from kilos, but it seems it’s a bit more.
By ana on Jun 15, 2007 | Reply
I actually had 58 kilo at my slimest time. And my goal is to have about 63-64, but more in muscle, less in fat. And there is also good fat and bad fat, at least on my body. Bad fat is this kind that a lot of skinny girls who don’t exercise get (Mischa Barton?)- more bloaty, just sitting ontop of your regular frame. Good fat I have very little of and would like to have more but I don’t really think my genetics will answer to that call.
By misstiffie on Jun 15, 2007 | Reply
I feel bad for celebs. They gain a few lbs and they’re suddenly “fat” and they lose weight or are skinny and automatically they’re slapped with the “eating disorder” thing. Blah!
By nwisbest on Jun 15, 2007 | Reply
Keira was NOT born skinny. There was a phase when she was actually very pear-shaped (not large, but not the size she is now or earlier when she was even skinnier). What I mean to say is that it’s not like she’s been the same weight forever. She was heavier, then lost weight and is now somewhere in between the two weights… In the last post, she looked like a perfectly healthy thin girl.
By Anna on Jun 15, 2007 | Reply
since when has being skinny become a crime?? it’s funny how quick people are to point a finger at someone underweight but yet you don’t see people walking up to someone overweight and asking, “geez, are you gonna eat all that?? you really don’t need to!”
By Ellie on Jun 15, 2007 | Reply
Doesn’t everyone say the exact same thing? I’m naturally thin…blah blah blah. Kate Moss said it until those photos came out of her doing coke. I don’t criticize anyone for not being thin as a rail. I’m not thin as a rail myself (although i’m still in shape). Keira Knightley has obviously had fluctuating weight. Everyone says she’s always been skinny. How long is always? Maybe 5-6 years? That doesn’t mean that she’s been amazingly skinny her entire life. In Bend It Like Beckham as I said, she had more weight on her. Her bones weren’t sticking out. If she can’t put on weight as she claims, then why after and only after that movie did she gradually begin to get skinnier and have her backbone showing? You can be skinny and eat a lot, but the fact of the matter is is that Keira was not always as skinny. What about the last post about her? Did she not put on weight? It’ll come off again obviously as it has done for a while. She claims she can’t put on weight, yet it’s obvious from certain photos as well as movies. At one point she said she thought she was too skinny and wanted to have a heavier frame, then she says she loves her skinny figure. So which is it? She’s back and forth back and forth. With her bone structure (which some people should learn about) she is NOT supposed to be as skinny as she is.
By jaime j on Jun 15, 2007 | Reply
I could believe that she didn’t have an eating disorder if it weren’t for her and Sienna’s stupid comments. It is definately possible to be that thin through strict diet and exercise. However, I refuse to believe she “eats like a pig.” That is just ridiculous. I am very thin naturally and can maintain a bmi of 17.5 with diet and exercise (like 1,500 cals/day and walking/jogging regularly), but that doesn’t mean I would still be really thin if I was eating pasta constantly (or whatever Keira said in that mag awhile back).
Also, if she weren’t anorexic, would it really be THAT big of deal if someone wrote that she was? I mean if you’re happy and eating and someone said you were not eating, you know what’s true, so why bother getting worked up about it?
By Karma on Jun 15, 2007 | Reply
Jaimi- I think it would be very annoying and insulting to constantly be scrutinized and attacked for the way you look. We have no idea what it’s like to be a celebrity and have all these stories, articles and pictures of us in magazines and online. Celebrities are human too and even though they know that their jobs are going to give them this type of attention, I still think they have the right and the ability to be affected by what others are saying. Just because she defends herself doesn’t make her guilty.
We can speculate all we want but we will never really know the truth behind any of these stories.
By ana on Jun 15, 2007 | Reply
Being called anorexic (in case you are not) and hating it is not getting worked up about nothing. It’s a serious thing, an illness. I don’t know if Keira has it or not, but if I put myself in her situation with all the: “she indirectly killed a girl” nonsense I would also become very angry and offended. Like, you are naturally pale and have dry skin and someone tells you that ergo you have an immune disorder or whatever. I find it rather unsettling that every skinny girl is now being labeled as a person with a disease.
Believe it or not, I ate cereal this morning, lunch in the afternoon and 4 different kinds of snacks in between (icecream, small bag of chips, Monte desert, bananas). I eat like that every day- 3 meals and a bunch of small snacks every couple of hours. I love pasta, kebab, burgers, pizza… and I do not gain weigth. If I don’t exercise, then I just become soft and flabby (if that is the correct word, excuse my English). If I exercise, then I have to eat like mentioned above, otherwise I’m loosing too much weigth. So, by my experience, it is possible to eat a lot and not be fat. I have a friend (male) who is 193 cm and hasn’t had more then 77 kilo in his life. At one point he was down to like 68. He really eats like a pig and hates that he is sooo painfully skinny but there’s not much he can do about it. I saw Keira in Bend it like Beckham, she looked a wee bit fuller than now, but it could easily be because she was quite young. I also had more to my cheeks and tummy when I was 18, 19.
By missy on Jun 15, 2007 | Reply
okay heres the truth.
none of us know for sure whether shes naturally like that (because there are people like that), has an ED (because she could have had it since Bend it), or does coke,excercise excessivley, whatever.
none of us know for sure and we all have valid arguements for each. but none of us know her personally so we cant really say.
By KatSpills on Jun 15, 2007 | Reply
Hmmm…I’ve actually never had a problem with the way Keira looks; I actually think she’s always been gorgeous and her weight seems perfectly fine. Sienna looks like she’s gained a few though.
By Sasha on Jun 15, 2007 | Reply
I hate both these bitches. Neither can act out of a bag, Keira’s voice is grating, Sienna is obnoxious. Both are too skinny and then normal and then skinny again, but even then, they both look drab. It’s fine if you lose weight while acting (i.e. Keira for Pirates shooting), but you don’t see Kate Winslet scowling and getting upset at gossip rags making accusations. If you don’t have a problem, you wouldn’t get so defensive. Sienna is such a famewhore on the other hand, she can’t help but put her friend down (honestly, eats like a pig?) and make a spectacle at any given moment. Both need to disappear off the face of the earth. Good fuckin’ riddance.
By y on Jun 15, 2007 | Reply
im gonna try to bulimic just for the sake of it, ive never been been much of an eater, but hell liestning to u guys, im going to be.im going to buy ice cream and macdonald or something and puke myself it cant be to bad right.wish me luck
By Fliss on Jun 15, 2007 | Reply
I’ve never been one of those naturally thin people with a fine bone structure, good metabolism etc but I can totally see what girls like Ana mean when they say it is crap to be labelled an anorexic. It is a serious mental disorder after all.
By Fliss on Jun 15, 2007 | Reply
And saying someone eats like a pig is not offensive unless they are overweight and it is mean’t in a cruel way. Sienna is just defending her friend by saying she has a healthy appetite and does not suffer from any mental illnesses that cause her to starve herself.
By doh on Jun 16, 2007 | Reply
to say that one wouldn’t care if one called you anorexic is just not true (well i guess some people don’t care).
I got called anorexic and bulimic and whatever while growing up , of courseonly by people who didnt like me, i eat alot and just didnt put on weight but itoo me they were very harsh words.
its very offensive to be called an anorexic if youre not.
because of what one stupid idiot at my school said behind my back the school nurse actually called my parents once just to make sure i was allright (which shocked my parents quite a bit since they know i eat like a horse and they basically wondered what she had been smoking:P).
its just not very fun being accused of having a disease that ruins so many peoples lives ok.
so no its not just something you can let go.
and to the person who said that kate winslet doesnt get upset about what people say about her weight. im pretty sure that she sued a magazine for stating that she was one some sort of freaky diet or something when she wasnt.
so yes people do get upset.
By Sacharomyces cerevisiae on Jun 16, 2007 | Reply
you are making such a big deal out of it. Miller is notorious for making derogatory, obnoxious insulting or just plain stupid comments. does anyone remember the sh%tsburgh story? she is a moron. I wouldnt take seriously anything that comes out of her pie hole
By Jesska on Jun 16, 2007 | Reply
Sienna was just trying to stick up for her. Being called that you “eat like a pig” is not that offensive if you look at the context especially as some mother blamed Kiera for the dealth of her daughter. Plus in the UK,being called that you eat like a pig is just like a joke..Sienna is her friend,so it’s not meant in a hurtful way.
Anorexia and Bulimia are serious diseases,so people shouldn’t speculate about them. They can cause serious distress to families and just labelling every celeb who is slightly thinner than most “anorexic” is just as hurtful as being called fat or ugly.
In hollywood it seems there is no happy medium so everyone seems to be criticised for being chubby/fat or far too skinny. Its totally messed up..so i feel pretty sorry for these girls.
By Jesska on Jun 16, 2007 | Reply
*death*
By Melissa on Jun 16, 2007 | Reply
Some of you people drive me insane. Many bulimics maintain a healthy weight or are overweight. And yes, IT IS possible to be that thin and eat a lot. Some people are just lucky. I know a few.
And stop accusing her of doing coke. She is barely even seen out partying. You are making accusations based on literally NO evidence. Stop being mean just because these celebrities have everything you never will.
By Sasha on Jun 17, 2007 | Reply
HAHAH, honey, being in the UK makes no difference. Yes, people in the states mockingly say ‘eat like a pig’ in a friendly manner, but coming from the mouth of Sienna Miller, who is notoriously known for her slanderous statements and complete lack of common sense, well, it’s definitely not a compliment. Keira’s lucky to have such a sweet kind friend, honestly. lol.
I hope Keira leaves the world of costume dramas and goes into Hollywood because she’s ruining every adaptation.
By rae rae trash on Jun 18, 2007 | Reply
Keira probably does eat alot…my cousin is like 5′7″ & eats so much junk food & weighs like 100lbs…. she has a very high metabolism… ever since shes been born… so yeah… sometimes girls just have it easier than me… I am like 5′4″ & weigh like 125…. whatev… my BF LOVES my body!!!!!!
By Anna on Jun 22, 2007 | Reply
“y, on June 15th, 2007 at 9:27 pm Said:
im gonna try to bulimic just for the sake of it, ive never been been much of an eater, but hell liestning to u guys, im going to be.im going to buy ice cream and macdonald or something and puke myself it cant be to bad right.wish me luck ”
wow! we have the privilege of speaking to the dumbest person alive!
By strawberry curls on Jun 23, 2007 | Reply
OMG I can’t believe all the comments. It’s funny how people start putting each other down over something like this. None of us know the truth, so why get all worked up over it? Not healthy. Anyway, I love Keira. I think she’s a good actress and she’s very pretty.
By Kim on Jun 24, 2007 | Reply
I wish these anorexia claims would stop. Yes, some people are skinny, and yes, some of those people happen to be anorexic. But I have friends who are super skinny but they eat like any normal person. People are born with different frames and in different shapes and sizes and sometimes their diet contributes to that. But there are a few skinny people who can eat ridiculously large amounts of food and whatever they want and still stay skinny. There people are annoying, admittedly
, but it’s not exactly their fault.
My larger point is, Keira has never been seen exactly to be dropping the pounds. It’s not like she was once perceived as a normal weight and then dropped weight to become skinny. As far as I can see she has ALWAYS been skinny. Her weight has never fluctuated beyond that of a normal person. She is one of those skinny people. So what? It’s not like with some famous people where someone has clearly come from having been a normal weight to something below their expected weight.
By sara on Jun 30, 2007 | Reply
almost all the celebrty are skinny now would you pleas stop saying that they are anoricxia she is nautrly skinny every one has made it pritty dam clear now i have an idea for her why dosent she make a realty show so she would show as that she can eat
By elle on Jul 2, 2007 | Reply
really sick of people whining about sienna’s use of “eats like a pig”, theyre friends and she is defending her i dont think keira cares how she phrases it if its her friend sticking up for her and is probably funny to keira espec if its true. plus i wish bloggers/commenters would stop talking about these people as if they know they think about it, you have NO way of knowing whether she is or not so stop speculating and speaking like you know her at all.
By sky on Aug 6, 2007 | Reply
I doubt she eats like a pig! Just because she eats and has a bit of apple crumble doesn’t make her a pig or bulimic. Sienna has no class in the way she puts things in most of her interviews, considering she went to one of the poshest boarding schools in England from when she was about 8! I think Kiera’s natur
By sky on Aug 6, 2007 | Reply
*naturally very thin but obviously doesn’t eat that much.
By barbra on Oct 14, 2007 | Reply
some skinny girls do eat like pigs. sometimes people actually do have super fast metabolisms. BUT KIERA knightly obviously doesnt.
sienna miller looks like re-fried dog doo here.
By Lital on Dec 27, 2007 | Reply
Question for ya?
What is this woman’s relevance to the world? The only thing she seems to do is walk around in impossibly ugly clothes with a silly grin on her face… I think she’s lovely, but I just don’t get what it is she does or why she’s so relevant that she seems to be in every magazine and/or celeb website…
By lemure on Feb 1, 2008 | Reply
LOL, all the back and forth on whether these women are anorexic or not, when is plain to see these Hollywood starlets are druggies more than anything else.