Keira Knightley Is Like, A Skeleton

August 29th, 2007 by Rian | Filed under Celebrity Bones, Keira Knightley.

Keira Knightley made an apperance at the Venice Film Festival earlier today (August 29th). There is no denying the fact that she - like too many other celebrities - is scary skinny. Skeletal skinny. In fact, she now officially qualifies as a lollipop head girl. (You know the type - the girl whose head is bigger than her body).

Particularly evident in this photo:
venice-film-festival-keira-knightley-30.jpg

Something is SERIOUSLY wrong here.

Honestly, when I first saw these photos, I did not recognize Keira. Because I can’t recall her EVER smiling before in a picture. She is so much prettier when she is smiling - I hope she does it more often from now on.

In the meantime, she needs to eat something(s). Fast.

venice-film-festival-keira-knightley-02.jpg

Come on, girl - what happened to those rumored curry meals you were downing to gain weight?



venice-film-festival-keira-knightley-04.jpg

venice-film-festival-keira-knightley-21.jpg


235 Responses to “Keira Knightley Is Like, A Skeleton”

  1. kelsey | 29/08/07

    First!!! She is soooo tiny. There is NO possible way that is natural. My guess…she’s going to be the next mk olsen.

  2. mamalisa | 29/08/07

    That is TINY!!!! She is almost invisible from the side

  3. Amy | 29/08/07

    OMFG this is a shame…Hollywood has gone insane. What wonderful role models they all are for this world. People need to get a grip,get help,live life for the things that are important.

  4. dani | 29/08/07

    Does Keira Knightley really think that she fooled us by saying she’s not anorexic or have some kind of eating disorder. Well she did not fool me. Keira needs to ear some bread and meat, and keep it in!

  5. Christine | 29/08/07

    BOBBLEHEAD. ugh, she’s so gorgeous but I really think she could do with some extra meat on her bones.

  6. none | 29/08/07

    unbelievable. that totally shocked me!!

  7. Anonymous Realist | 29/08/07

    She looks gorgeous.

  8. shady | 29/08/07

    WOW…makes me feel kinda fat

  9. Helen | 29/08/07

    gross, she is 5′7 and looks about 90 pounds -_- looks like she’s been taking a leaf from AJ, Jenna Jameson, and Posh. I love and admire her too, its so sad :(

  10. Cocottenubs | 29/08/07

    She’s a bobblehead and fabulous looking at the same time. You can see her hip bones protruding in the last pic. Fabulous dress. I agree that she looks way too skinny but at the same time, she looks INCREDIBLE.

  11. Kittah | 29/08/07

    She doesn’t look so bad in most of the photos but in the first one, it looks like her head has been enlarged with photoshop or something!

  12. Golden | 29/08/07

    She does look entirely too thin, esp in the first…but for some reason she looks gorgeous. i heart the open mouth smiles :)

  13. apricotmuffins | 29/08/07

    ah, i wondered how long it would take for these to be posted.

    I know that keira is naturally very slim, but she looks far too thin here, even for a naturally slim person. she’s all brittle and hard looking….

    She’s such a beautiful girl, i hope she isnt going to destroy herself. :(

  14. Jeneroni | 29/08/07

    now SHE is fabulous… i dont give a darn if shes stick thin or has curves made for luvin, she is incredibly talented and insanely beautiful…
    right on KEIRA!

  15. Anon | 29/08/07

    She looked a lot prettier when she was about 10 lbs. heavier. 10 pounds more would probably still put her at a size 0!

  16. Natalia D | 29/08/07

    Keira is slim yes, but she has small bones. I am sure her BMI is above 16. There are no protruding bones.

    if she as at 90 pounds, she would be about the same as angelina jolie, she looks healthy but slim.

  17. H | 29/08/07

    i think her thin-ness is accentuated by the fact that she has no boobs or a stomache.. otherwise, ther arms looks pretty normal.

  18. Mary | 29/08/07

    She doesn’t look that thin. I think it is just clever dressing. You have to remember that she carries most of her weight in her hip and thigh area, which is hidden. The dress also draws atention to the area just below the bust line, which is the thinnest part of any female.

  19. Erica | 29/08/07

    BMI above 16? I thought a healthy BMI was *18*.

  20. Erica | 29/08/07

    And yes, she’s a gross skeleton.

  21. crowb | 29/08/07

    She has proportionately rather large legs which is why she always wears long gowns, I think it’s possible she just looks really thin up top because she keeps all her weight in them.

    But I think she looks kind of strange with the large head thing and her arm posing makes it worse. Something about her forehead seems wrong to me too…

  22. Steph | 29/08/07

    Natalia D, a BMI under 17.5 is part of the criteria in diagnosing anorexia. I hope she’s above a 16.

  23. Meg | 29/08/07

    It’s a sad state of affairs when the phrase “there are no protruding bones” has become the way we determine if a woman’s weight is “healthy.”

  24. Dee | 29/08/07

    Natalie, what plenty are you on. 90lb at 5ft7 is not slim nor healthy.

    She is clearly small boned and may weigh less than the average 5ft7 female, but no way does she need to be 20lb underweight, that is ridiculous. She is not some girl in her early teens, she is a grown woman!

  25. Dee | 29/08/07

    Sorry correction, make that 30lb underweight! That is 25% underweight for her height and would come under severely underweight.

  26. Anonymous Realist | 29/08/07

    Erica, by fat American standards I think “healthy” goes all the way to 20. Hard to believe but true.

  27. Lenore | 29/08/07

    you know, i saw this picture and all i could see at first was her face, and I thought “wow, she looks beautiful.” …..then, I scrolled down and was utterly dissapointed with the rest.

  28. Dee | 29/08/07

    And one more thing, when you lose weight too quickly or starve yourself you lose muscle so your build looks smaller. She looked healthy in her ‘bend it like bekham days’, when she was thin but lean.

  29. Dee | 29/08/07

    Anonymous realist acceptable BMI goes up to 25. But that doesn’t matter anyway, it’s your body fat that’s important…… no point having a BMI of under 20 if you have 32% body fat. On the other hand a BMI of over 25 with 22% body fat is great.

  30. julie | 29/08/07

    It’s funny, but if you kind of look back at when she starred at that movie The Hole, she was alredy that skinny, also at Bend it like Beckham, no change in that.
    She may be pretty thin, but just look at her arms, usually girls who are too skinny for their body tipe have all those veins protuding, as well as the chest bone, she hasn’t got either.
    Maybe she’s just that thin naturally, i’ve known people who are like that, they have to struggle not to get too thin, imagine that, so horrible right? Having to eat a lot in order not to get skinny. I’d hate it if it were me, haha!

  31. MMH | 29/08/07

    Wow, she looks really tiny; especially in that picture taken from the side view! It’s strange though, her arms look normal size, but everywhere else she looks to thin.

  32. Dee | 29/08/07

    The only reason she doesn’t have protruding veins and bones is because she has lost a tonne of muscle and still has normal percentage of body fat.

    OMG I can’t believe how many times I’ve posted!

  33. Chelsey | 29/08/07

    Aside from the fact that yes, she does look very skinny, she also looks so cute when she smiles…every picture we see her in she seems so depressed or moody, but she looks incredible here- especially cute in the third pic!

  34. Melissa | 29/08/07

    What the heck happened to her!?!
    Holy GEEZE!

  35. C | 29/08/07

    I think it’s partially the dress. She is really skinny, but the dark bottom in contrast with the white top makes her bottom half look tinier than it is. I’m doubtful that she’s any skinnier than she’s ever been. I would say a loss of 5 pounds or less from her usual weight.
    I would also hazard a guess that she has a very high metabolism and that this is a natural weight for her. We haven’t really ever seen her much higher than this, but she never dips much lower either.
    She’s on the very thin side of things, but she looks happy and healthy to me!

  36. Diane | 29/08/07

    wow- i really have no words…wow!

  37. emogurl | 29/08/07

    She looks pretty fantastic except in the 2nd photo there’s something strange going on with her face. But yeah, she could stand to gain maybe 10 pounds and still be ultra ultra thin.

  38. what she said | 29/08/07

    she will die trying to los that ass of hers. face it keira, you have rather larger hips compared to your upper body. you cant just be assless and be alive -in your case. and she is not 15 anymore. why the hell cant she be ready to face life, and stop bothering with superficial obsessions?

  39. Denise | 29/08/07

    Not cute at all. She looked so much better in that movie “Love Actually” when she actually had a little weight on her.

  40. mazz | 29/08/07

    Shes very thin but I still think she looks nice

  41. mazz | 29/08/07

    And that dress, it makes her seem sooooooooo tall

  42. ~*bonez*~ | 29/08/07

    Are you kidding me Erica? The lowest healthy BMI is 18.5! If she’s 16 then she needs medical intervention for whatever it is that’s wrong. I don’t know if it’s an eating disorder or drugs, or something else but she is sick looking and it’s shocking to see her.

    It doesn’t take a shrink to know something’s very wrong. I always thought she “Doeth protest too much ” when she came out and said she didn’t even know what anorexia was.

    I was in hospital against my will when my weight dropped and my BMI was 15.9 I almost died b/c I went into cardiac arrest.

    Just wonder what she looks like in person. She might not be on deaths door step, but if she keeps at this rate, it won’t take long until she is.

  43. tim jones | 29/08/07

    I prefer women who I can’t curl easily

  44. brookelynn | 29/08/07

    Wow, her head looks like a bad photoshop job. Particularly in the second picture.
    She is tiiiny.

  45. Natalie | 29/08/07

    I think she’s gorgeous, a little thin, but still gorgeous.

  46. sassy | 29/08/07

    what happened to her, she use to look so healthy and gorgeous.
    she’s really looking too skinny here, omg, i hope she stop what ever she’s doing.

  47. KiKi | 29/08/07

    Anonymous Realist. I hope you are joking with your BMI comments, if not you need SERIOUS help. You are considered underweight if you are have a BMI under 18. Normal is like 18 to 24.5. I am 5′4 and 125lbs am a marathon runner, have an athletic build and am a size 2-4. I definately do NOT consider myself fat at all & I have a BMI of 21.5, by your standards obese. Scary…

  48. D | 29/08/07

    i think she looks great but then again i have issues with weight so yea

  49. Maxx05 | 29/08/07

    I’d need to see her bottom half not covered to be able to say whether she’s really lost weight. she looks very pretty. She is thinnest on top.

  50. Strawberry curls | 29/08/07

    I love Keira! She’s so beautiful, but I hope nothing bad happens to her. :( She looks like she’s lost tons more weight.

  51. wendy | 29/08/07

    no boobs.
    disgusting.
    eck.

  52. Anonymous | 29/08/07

    She looks thin but, she is very bottom heavy. I have a friend that is shaped like her. Very very thin on top, but has large hips and legs. If you look at all the pictures of Keira, youshould note that her legs, never ever look really thin. Just her arms and chest.

  53. Gwen | 29/08/07

    I think Kiera is one of those who are definitely naturally slim, especially
    in the upper body area. But you can tell she still has a butt in the first picture! I’ve have tons of friends who’re like that. Skinny upper bodies, with athletic legs. They look perfectly normal to me.

    She is looking pretty in that dress and smile :)

  54. LC | 29/08/07

    If you look at the second pic, her lower half can’t be *that* big. There’s no way! Her hips are too slim.

  55. Karma | 29/08/07

    God DAMN!! She it freakin’ tiny.
    It’s nice to see her smiling for once (even if it is fake).
    And yes- she is insanely skinny.
    I don’t know know how she finds belts that fit that freakin’ waist…

  56. Jacqueline | 29/08/07

    hey, standard bmi is actually like 18-24, and 20 is totally not fat. thinking that a bmi of 20 is fat is hysterical, especially since bmi doesn’t factor in muscle mass, bone mass, and gender. a fit, slim person can have a bmi of like 23 and still be considered “skinny”.

  57. Natalia D | 29/08/07

    It’s just cause she has no boobs, so her upper half looks tiny. I think she is fit, slightly slim but with 5 pounds and she would be sweet as.

  58. Cookie | 29/08/07

    The only thing attractive about her is her arms. Her hair is nasty, she has almost no breasts (and not in a cute way)…. who cares about a tiny waist if the rest of you looks like an under-fed horse?

  59. emma | 29/08/07

    her head is just tooo big for the rest of her skinny body

  60. emma | 29/08/07

    her head is just tooo big for the rest of her skinny body

  61. Dardar | 29/08/07

    the second pic is the scariest, other than that she looks alright.. as long as she’s smiling

  62. Kristi | 29/08/07

    dude
    WTF do celebs think is so attractive about looking this skinny

    plus the camera adds ten pounds….

    she has no boobs!

  63. DaveW | 29/08/07

    This is absolutely insane. Anyone woman who finds this in any way attractive or healthy has a severely warped sense of femininity and any (straight) man who finds this attractive is going to appear on “to Catch a Predator” soon, she looks prepubescent. Your head is NOT supposed to be larger than your body and she has no breasts, they’re simply not there. Oh and BTW, a healthy BMI actually goes to 25. This would be relevant and important if BMI was actually a good measure of anything.

  64. maddison | 29/08/07

    In the last pic, she’s doing that puckered, semi-parted-lips-look similar to what the Olsens do (only theirs look more ‘duck-ish’) for a high cheekbone effect. We get it, you’re thin. Stop trying so hard.

  65. Stephanie | 29/08/07

    Now this?!?!

    I’m almost inclined to think that she’s being inappropriately sarcastic BECAUSE OF the media scrutiny. That second photo is screaming “smartass.”

  66. gg | 30/08/07

    she looks great-why do you think she looks so much thinner than before? She looks the same as usual-just not photoshopped to have bigger boobs or whatever for a movie promo. Some people are naturally thin.

  67. Kristin | 30/08/07

    She doesn’t have any protruding bones, so she looks good. She’s thin, its her body type.

  68. Kim | 30/08/07

    So it was one of those moments in which I see a scary headline and see the top part of the accompanying photo, which doesn’t look bad at all (I mean, look at her, she really is gorgeous). Then I scroll down and almost fall out of my chair as I see the full body shot! Poor Keira! It looks like any day she can just faint and die. I don’t mean to be so blunt and I don’t mean to kid. I’m totally serious and totally worried. Forget her defense that she was born thin. She definitely neither is nor looks healthy. If she really is telling the truth, I think it should be considered an inherited illness.

  69. Marmelade | 30/08/07

    ‘Erica, by fat American standards I think “healthy” goes all the way to 20. Hard to believe but true.’

    probably hard for you to believe, but somethings wrong with your head and perception. if a person with a bmi aorund 20 seems unhealthily fat for you for you then, seriously… its you with a problem, not they.

  70. fatbetch | 30/08/07

    unfortunate.

  71. Joelle | 30/08/07

    Have the photos been ’shopped??

    She looks unreal.

    If they weren’t, she waaaay too skinny. Yuck. That NOT a woman’s body.

  72. Anais | 30/08/07

    oh man, that’s so sad. I really like her as an actress, and I think she has a beautiful face - but in these pictures she looks horribly skinny. her hair looks brittle… I hope she’ll gain some weight soon.

  73. hi | 30/08/07

    I’ve always wondered Anonymous Realist was male or female.

  74. Alexia | 30/08/07

    I don’t think she is SO skinny and as people above have said, she carries most of her weight on her hip area!

    Clever dressing!

  75. denise | 30/08/07

    For God’s sake people..this woman is naturally thin. No chest bones are visible..no veiny arms…she looks gorgeous. Absolute perfection.

  76. edie s. | 30/08/07

    she is thin yes. But I think it is still beautifull and not skeletal

  77. julia | 30/08/07

    *sigh*…i love Keira so much! i just bought Flare with her on the cover…she looks amazing though on a bit of a thin side..now i see why! She’s so thin…im scared to admit that i find her extremely beautiful anyway..

  78. Nina | 30/08/07

    wow, she looks really strange inthe first 3 photos. looks quite normal, in terms of face, in the last.

  79. Jasmine | 30/08/07

    i recently saw another pic of her -in a white dress that has a pink bow and she looked amazing.

  80. Ladybird | 30/08/07

    Marmalade… that’s what I was about to say.
    Anyhow, these pics are horrible, she is way too thin.

  81. Beck | 30/08/07

    she looks even thinner in that new film she’s in, the novel adaptation i can’t remember the name an english classic though.

  82. Frankie | 30/08/07

    Keira, what happened to u? WHERE is the rest of ur back?
    :-(

  83. REALYY | 30/08/07

    NO BOOBS, NO ASS => NO WOMAN !!!

    IT IS SO SAD, BECAUSE SHE COULD BE SO CUTE AND BEAUTIFUL, I JUST HOPE THAT SHE’LL STOP FOOLING HERSELF AND ADMIT THAT SHE HAS A PROBLEM.
    I HOPE SHE’LL GET BETTER.
    NOW, SHE LOOKS FUNNY WITH HER HEAD TO BIG FOR HER TINY BODY, THAT IS NOT NATURAL AND BEAUTIFUL.

    GOOD LUCK

  84. breads | 30/08/07

    if this ain’t an eating disorder, tell me what is?
    you don’t need petruding bones to be underwieght

  85. bella | 30/08/07

    I don’t think she’s scary skinny…she always has this lollipop head look also when she was heavier and very fit (when she was on the set of domino and king arthur)…it is impossible to say how skinny she is because the dress cover her legs and remember that she has the upper body very thin,much thinner then legs..

  86. bella | 30/08/07

    and I don’t understand all this rumors about an ED…keira is always been skinny,she has gained only for movie rules..I understand rumors about nicole richie who never was skinny in the past but about keira…

  87. Sacharomyces cerevisiae | 30/08/07

    well…

  88. Sacharomyces cerevisiae | 30/08/07

    she still has an ass-the dress is a tad too long and wide to reveal it. she looks sh*teous in the face though

  89. Prinzz | 30/08/07

    It’s true that she looks prettier while smiling.

  90. Baby | 30/08/07

    If you can’t see that she is far too skinny something is wrong with you my friend.

  91. Violet | 30/08/07

    I think Kiera’s been the unfortunate victim of a nasty photoshop experiment!

  92. Lucy | 30/08/07

    I think she looks ok. Shes pear shaped. Shes always been very skinny up top, and fuller in her bottom half. She just looks particularly skinny here because you can’t see her bottom half. She has a lost a bit of weight, but probs only coz she has been working. I wish people would stop saying shes anorexic.

  93. Sara | 30/08/07

    Hmmm… fat European standards say that 19-24 is normal BMI, 25 and ove slightly overweight and 18 is too skinny.

    Being 5.8 tall I have been both 24.6 (170 lb) and 19.2 (132 lb). 24 was actually quite bad but 19 was already very slim, I almost look anorexic in my wedding photos (which sucks). With BMI 16 I would weigh as much as I did when I was 14… not a very ideal look.

  94. causethisiswhyi'mhot | 30/08/07

    i think she is one of those people,who despite being really rather too thin,still looks stunning facially,so no one really pays attention to her weight.they’re all too busy staring at her face.but saying that,she’s never been anything other than really,really slender.i don’t think it’s fair to say that she either has an eating disorder or is the cause of them.leave the girl alone

  95. misellsneous | 30/08/07

    This girl is definitely underweight. I would not be surprised if her bmi WAS 16. Shes just as skinny as before the ‘curry fest’. Emphasis on the ‘ ‘.

    Basically, below 18.5 is underweight.. ie. you have to put on more to be considered healthy. Of course this will vary from person to person, but those are the guidelines given by the British Government. I personally have a bmi of around 20, am 5′9 and a size 8UK.. If that makes me fat then I’d like to know what your idea of obese is.

  96. chri | 30/08/07

    I agree with bella. even though I can’t help but notice her malnutrished looking hair and the nailpolish.

  97. !! | 30/08/07

    i think she looks disgusting and whoever thinks her body looks good is seriously disordered

  98. Alice | 30/08/07

    She has always been tiny, she has a small bust and a tiny waist. The style of the dress emphasises this.

    She is not too thin. If she was too thin then we would see bones and veins in her arms. Her arms are perfectly healthy looking.

    She is beautiful. You lot need to get a grip. Some of the people on this site that you describe as ’scary skinny’ are actually just normal sized.

    You cannot keep putting the problem onto those who are slim or fit and healthy, just because you are obese in comparison but don’t want to face up to reality.

  99. kim | 30/08/07

    she looks good

  100. sky | 30/08/07

    eww, she’s way to skinny. I’m not sure weather it’s deliberate or not but it’s defintly not her bodys natural weight, i bet her bmi is very low. And if the camera adds 10 pounds! She has such a beautiful face is well i don’t know why she’s bothered, she could be a size 18 and still look pretty lol.

  101. Jode | 30/08/07

    I am soo shocked! I used to love Keira Knightley!!! But what in hell would possess someone to think looking that thin looks good?

    Hollywood needs better role models!

  102. Stephanie | 30/08/07

    Celebrities and sports figures are not role models, by definition.

    That is the problem with society, and all of these folks who seem to operate with that assumption should realize that no one can (or should) try to live up to that standard. They’re human, and they’re going to screw up, and parents need to teach their children this really damn quick.

  103. mimi | 30/08/07

    come on people! she ALWAYS has been skinny and I don’t think she has lost more weight here.
    to be honset the first 2 pics really look a little shocking, but it’s just the camera angle. don’t you remember she carries her weight at the bottom part and since it’s covered only her tiny frame at the top is exposed. but she doesn’t have any protruding bones, which no matter what someone said IS a sign of NOT being too underweight. she’s fine, just a tiny girl.
    and about all that cr*p about BMIs. I think it’s time people to understand that they are not reliable. I myself have always had a BMI below 17, in all points of my life ( and I’m 20 now), sometimes even lower. My doctor has never had problems with that and never told me I should gain weight.. Also very few people have ever told me I look too thin. But I am average height. On the other hand my best friend, who is 176 cm ( about 5.9 ) has always looked underweight to me although she weighs a “healthy” 61 kg ( 135 lbs) and I just calculated that her BMI is around 20. Seriously, I cannot believe people are still using BMIs as a criterion wheter one is or not too skinny (underweight). Some people just have small frames and are naturally light, while others are heavily built and must weight more in order to be healthy.

  104. Kelsey M | 30/08/07

    I think she looks great. Also, she smiles all the time. I agree with Denise “No chest bones are visible..no veiny arms…she looks gorgeous.” Also, I love the fact that she is flat chested. Too many women go out and get fake breast. Keira is just being who she is.

  105. plastichearts | 30/08/07

    shes disgustingly thin.
    shes beautiful, but shes slowing killing herself..

  106. mona | 30/08/07

    Love the dress! She is one of he most beautiful women I’ve ever seen, but she def. looks better with a few more pounds on her.

  107. Miss M | 30/08/07

    I don’t know if she is any thinner to be honest.

    She’s always been very thin and you have to stop comparing her with how she was in “bend it like beckham” because that was years ago and she hadn’t finished growing then. I don’t think she will ever be a “big girl”, she is just naturally thin. And yes, even naturally thin people have ups and downs, maybe she just had some stress and lost a few pounds.

    I highly doubt that Keira fell for the whole US size zero craze. She said the other day she would happily give it all up. She is also not the person who gives a monkey what the current fashionable weight is.

  108. Ana | 30/08/07

    she looks okay, but the red nailpolish… UGLY!

  109. MITZE | 30/08/07

    ithink she looks good. she has always been thin. some people are just small.

  110. Phineas Gage | 30/08/07

    She’s always been skinny. Skinny, gorgeous, and skinny.

  111. Snow White | 30/08/07

    If you look at her hair, it looks dull, stringy, and dry. That’s a huge indicator that she is malnourished. I wouldn’t be suprised if some of her hair is thinning by now. It looks that way.

  112. tara | 30/08/07

    am i the only onethat doesnt think that she is too skinny? although i agree that this weight not be the healthiest for her. she looks a little haggard and tired.

  113. Genevieve Jules | 30/08/07

    She looks the same as she ever was. I do not think she looks bad at all.

  114. Hun | 30/08/07

    She screams malnourished - EAT girl EAT!!! She’s so beautiful, but at this too-thin weight, she’s not doing her natural beauty justice.

  115. breads | 30/08/07

    i just remembered who her stylist is, the same evil woman who made nicole richie stylish and introduced her to the art of not eating

  116. Ash | 30/08/07

    I think she’s naturally thin.

    She looks a little thinner here than her usual, but if she gained like five pounds she would look totally normal for her.

    I like her body, and she’s a great actress, and she’s really funny and down to earth.

    Honestly I think people should just leave her alone,
    because if she does have any body issues/eating issues - and I’d say MOST women do,
    being in the spotlight and told “You’re too skinny!” can be JUST as harmful as pointing out that someone’s too fat.

    Maybe she just CAN’T gain weight, I’ve known girls like that before, and it’s not like they weren’t trying.

  117. E-Elle | 30/08/07

    NO BOOBS, NO ASS => NO WOMAN !!!

    Erm. Okay, that’s actually really offensive.

    I don’t understand her. I mean she does look too thin. Her head is far too big for her body. But.. she doesn’t look bony. She doesn’t look ‘anorexic’

    Maybe she is just naturally like that. I mean she’s never been more than maybe 10 pounds heaveier…

  118. m. | 30/08/07

    i love her, she looks skinny but awesome.

  119. liese | 30/08/07

    tjeeez, i hope someone will intervene!!!

  120. Jen | 30/08/07

    She’s so gorgeous! But she’s super skinny…it’s just too tiny. She’s naturally small though. She can’t help it that her body is built that way.

  121. tallgirl | 30/08/07

    I agree that she is naturally skinny but I think that she pushes it. You know what I mean? If she is truly her reported weight of 5′7 then she probably SHOULD naturally weigh about 115 pounds but instead she weights 95-100.

  122. Ally | 30/08/07

    I think the only part that looks super thin on her is her chest/torso area and that is ALWAYS thin on her. Her arms don’t look skinny and her legs are always heavier than the rest of her. I think her face looks horrible in these pictures though. I don’t think she looks very pretty in the smiling ones at all.
    In general I don’t think she takes candid photographs well and looks much better (absolutely gorgeous) on video.

  123. harley | 30/08/07

    Oh Boy! These picture have “look at me” all over it! She is probably one of the most annoying celebs out there, I can see right through her its insane! First her “im not anorexic” then her “i just want to quit acting forever to escape the media frenzy”, PUh-Lease! She all of a sudden after pirates aint to much in the spotlight (and it seems like her movie career aint the greatest right now either) and now all of a sudden this! I think for someone who doesnt want to be called “anorexic” sure does everything she possibly can to appear thinner then she already is! I just saw more of this pictures and in pretty much all of them shes trying incredibly hard to look thin! Her body language is so apparent shes doing all the skinny poses (just look at em and youll see), so im guessing this is going to work, all of a sudden shell be in every tabloid magazine there is now, just watch. goo job keira! Blah! shes so full of shit!

  124. Annika | 30/08/07

    Wow, skinny! LOVE the dress, especially the skirt. She really does look like a smart ass in those top pics…. I love her personality in her interviews; she has a hilarious sense of humor. I hope she doesn’t get any thinner!

  125. Never teh Bride | 30/08/07

    Eh, can’t say I like this look much.

  126. charlotte | 30/08/07

    In the last picture, with her directly facing the camera, she doesn’t look too skinny. I mean, she’s obviously very thin, but like everyone else has said, it’s just natural for her. It’s just a very slim upperbody. Plus, I think the vertical lines down the navy part of the dress elongate her torso and make her seem even thinner. She’s lovely when she’s smiling.

  127. Hillie | 30/08/07

    What are you people talking about?! A healhy BMI goes from 18.5-24.9 or thereabouts. 16 is underweight! 20 is on the low side of normal. I don’t think the ranges have been changed anytime in the recent past to accomodate “fat American” standards. That’s just ridiculous!

  128. cossey | 30/08/07

    Oops…her tittys disappeared! If I did her….I’d hurt her!

  129. dzd | 30/08/07

    … I actually thinks she looks fat now, she was HOT when she was really skinny.

  130. Steph | 30/08/07

    She wouldn’t look nearly as skinny if she had any boobs at all…. I think she looks a little creepy.

  131. kj | 30/08/07

    the pictures look altered to me for some reason.

  132. luran | 30/08/07

    She’s so pretty when she smiles. It’s so sad she’s not eating. She looks beautiful without starving herself!!

  133. ANONBLONDE | 30/08/07

    She is definately in scary skinny territory now…it’s a shame…

  134. Kelsey M | 30/08/07

    Harley - “and it seems like her movie career aint the greatest right now either” What? Atonement, Silk, The Edge of Love, The Duchess….

  135. bitbit | 30/08/07

    she does look scary in the first picture. but only because of what she’s doing with her face. doesn’t look like a smile to me. otherwise she looks good and I love her with the dark hari

  136. Shannon | 30/08/07

    Gross. Look at her face and neck in the second picture. She looks to be 40 years old. Like I keep on saying…if you are that self conscious to get that skinny you should realize that losing too much ages you so much. Nothing wrong with being tiny and in shape like Eva Longoria but the emanciated look is so ugly.

  137. bella | 30/08/07

    some comments are very crazy and sad…everyone know that keira is always been this skinny,always except when she was heavier for movie rules(she always says that it’s very hard for her put on a few pounds)so..why do you think she’s anorexic?when you see a thin people in your real life you think that she-he has an ED for sure??
    It’s very strange,in my country thare isn’t all this attention and this rumors about celeb weight and nobody think that a thin girl must have some sort of eating disorder…

  138. lizz | 30/08/07

    just because some one has protruding bones doesn’t mean they have an eating disorder… i know everyone will disagree with me, but i know this one lady at my work who is a STICK but eats a lot of junk. she’s also 5′0, so i think its just genetic for her.
    anyways, keira looks so pretty! being this thin suits her. if it’s forced, lets not chastise her for it!

  139. MIMI | 30/08/07

    OH WAIT ! I SEE NOTHING.

  140. Amber | 30/08/07

    CAN WE SAY PHOTOSHOP??!! These are so not real!!

  141. Harley | 30/08/07

    I don’t mean to say that to piss off her “fans” Im just saying the more you’re in the spotlight the more people are interested in you, the better your career. It all comes down to money, if people want to see you in a movie the more roles you’ll get offered. She exactly doesn’t do a lot of diverse character roles, and that one she did “Domino” was horrible. In my opinion shes still behind Scarlet Johanson, just because people have more interest in her for some reason and Scarlett seems to have more diverse movie roles, both for mainstream ones and not (and shes also a good actress, which matters somewhat). All I’m saying is its definitely a planned career move thats all.

  142. cellulite eXpert | 30/08/07

    look at the last picture, her saddlebags are standing away from her dress. what would you all do if you had this body type? would you stay skinny or gain weight and end up with thunder thighs? her upper body won’t gain weight noticeably until all her fat cells are maxed out in the lower half. she would be considered bottom heavy with another 10-15 pounds on her.

  143. Liztron | 30/08/07

    She needs to eat a hamburger regardless if she is healthy or not.

  144. Rachel | 30/08/07

    I actually don’t think she looks that bad. I have a friend who’s about that size and eats a freaking TON. SO maybe she’s one of those metabolism high people, because face it, when have we seen her fat?

  145. lambman | 30/08/07

    she looks so skinny and definetly needs to gain some weight.

    have you seen that coco Mademoiselle ad she’s in? She looks like a freaking Halloween display you just have to paint her weight and you’ve got a skeleton!

  146. Edan | 30/08/07

    Well… I think I will keep my breasts, thanks.

  147. lambman | 30/08/07

    though to be honest, part of me thinks this may just be her natural size…look at her arms and compare them to say Jenna Jamison or Angelina…they both have gross skinny vainy arms, but Kiera’s arms look completely fine to me when I think of the other two.

  148. Y. | 30/08/07

    i dont really think that those are saddlebags. i think its the design of the dress.

  149. Line | 30/08/07

    I agree with the anti-the red nail polish comment!

  150. Persephone | 30/08/07

    She may be naturally thin, but I agree the person that said she pushes it. She keeps her weight below what it naturally wants to be regardless of whether she is naturally thin or not.

    Part of me thinks she looks great, the other part realizes how horrible she looks. This is obviously not her natural size. She looks sick.

  151. Barbie_Princess | 30/08/07

    She really is shockingly skinny.

  152. nazan | 30/08/07

    VERY skinny. but that’s not the problem i have with her. it’s mainly her inability to act.

  153. elise | 30/08/07

    I know people who are this skinny naturally but the difference between them and Keira is that Keira used to be a lot heavier! Several tens of pounds heavier! You don’t magically become naturally skinny. I’m sure she’s enjoying the pretense though.

  154. Sarah | 30/08/07

    WHAT THE HELL HAPPENED TO HER!?!?

    She used to be so gorgeous, healthy, and slim.

    Now she looks like a little girl!

    Her shoulders bones are jutting right out!

    Poor girl.

  155. mellers | 30/08/07

    I don’t think she is too thin. Thinner than recent but she often fluctuates (like most women). And this is in her normal range.

    I would love to have her body.

    Keira Knightley is truly the most beautiful woman in film.

  156. Elaine | 30/08/07

    Unnaturally thin, she’s not eating. She would look much better yet still thin with 10 pounds more.

  157. Dahlia | 30/08/07

    how is that skinny? sure she’s flat-chested and has no stomach, but she has a butt and some poundage in the lower region. i think she has a fantastic body in fact!

  158. Lucy | 30/08/07

    She does look very thin but hasn’t she always been this way.

  159. the confused | 30/08/07

    That looks ugly, Horrific posture is not helping either.
    She looks sick.
    But I think the implants would help to balance her out, because she does have a larger lower body.

  160. conscience | 30/08/07

    she looks great.

  161. tiny4eva | 30/08/07

    She is thin. I don’t think she’s anorexic but she’s veryclose to becoming one.

    She’s always had a tiny upper body. I noticed it on the premiere of POTC when she wore the white cropped tank with the jeans. She has a heavy bottom (thighs) so I’m assuming that was what she noticed and wanted to slim down. The dress doesn’t help her because it highlights her top and disguises her bottom. As it is, she has no hips.

    She needs to gain some weight because I don’t believe she can stay healthy like this but to me she’s not at the point that Anorexics are.

  162. cossey | 30/08/07

    Seek help mellers….seek help now!

  163. ~*~katie~*~ | 30/08/07

    mellers….im not trying to give you a hard time about your comments but honestly…..you would want to look like her? it looks like some popped the head off her body and stuck it on some incredibly tall/lanky looking 11 year old girl……she looks so soo unhealthy and un natural in that second picture….i cant get over it

  164. Lillifee | 30/08/07

    I love her and her body! She’s great. I wanna have her body!

  165. erin | 30/08/07

    Please, she’s always been skinny. I don’t think she looks unhealty, I think she looks great! She hasn’t been jojo-ing like several other celebritys, she’s naturally that way! Go Keira:)

  166. mklover | 30/08/07

    her hips and waist look tiny. in some bikkin pics her legs look alot heaver compaired to her top half. im pear shaped myself so i no that when you try and loose weight of your bottom half it comes of the top first so maybe thats were shes coming from with the weight loss. shes always been slim but in these pics shes took it to far and dusnt look good for the loss. shes lost her glow

  167. kateb | 30/08/07

    I cannot BELIEVE that some people here genuinely dont think her arms look skinny. Imagine what they look like in PERSON.

  168. skinnyhappy | 30/08/07

    LOLLIPOP!

  169. Renee | 30/08/07

    it’s those top 2 photos.. she is very thin. I agree with mimi about bmi’s. people think im underweight, even though according to some BMI scales im not.
    But I do think kierra is underweight. her hands and wrists are bony, her face, she IS bony.

  170. jenny | 30/08/07

    kiera FRIGHTLY. GROSS GROSS GROSS

    almost looks like POSH-sicle

  171. Jennie | 30/08/07

    Whether it’s natural or not, she looks terrible. Yuck.

  172. Serendipity | 30/08/07

    The backlash of skinny becoming the new normal (and normal becoming the new fat) in Hollywood. Who can say they’re really suprised?

  173. Emily | 30/08/07

    She looks very thin, but I don’t think she looks emaciated. I think that thait is her natural weight. She’ll probably put more weight on has time goes on….

  174. Raha | 30/08/07

    She looks AWFUL!!!
    You can only be underweight if you undereat. That’s a fact, metabolism has not much to do with it. “Naturally” skinny people just have naturally good eating habits.
    She never used to be THIS skinny. When she was 16 in “The hole” she actually had some arms left. She is at least 15lbs thinner now.

  175. Nele | 30/08/07

    And my boyfriend still thinks she looks sexy OMG -.- what a desaster

  176. midnight | 30/08/07

    these are the scariest-skinny pics of her I’ve seen. really worrying :-(

  177. SandanistaGirl | 30/08/07

    Keira the British Bratz Doll!

  178. Ala | 30/08/07

    skinny yes, but you have to admit she has a BEAUTIFUL look for editorials and film. Stunning on screen.

  179. Ultra skinny girl | 30/08/07

    She reminds me of myself!I look like that from the side.

  180. Alyssa | 30/08/07

    She is beyond talanted and extremely beautiful. Maybe she’s lost some weight for a movie role.

    I think she looks great.

  181. cossey | 30/08/07

    Yeah…her new movie role is playing a light pole!

  182. kaddi | 30/08/07

    I do not think she has an eating disorder…she looks petit…but when you take a look at her arms you really see she is just thin/normal. someone with an e.d. would have slimmer arms. the problem: she doesn´t have breast any more…so where are they? maybe gone when she lost her weight some months ago when she was much thinner…

  183. heather | 30/08/07

    She is so tiny that it kind of hurts to look at her now., which is a shame because she is usually stunning.

  184. Meems | 30/08/07

    Oh my heck. She looks like……a flag pole. But even skinnier.

  185. Ams | 30/08/07

    I don’t think she’s ano. She’s always been very thin.

  186. Elle | 30/08/07

    What happened to those curry meals with Sienna? Sheesh! She looks so tiny! And so pleased with herself to be at this low weight. To me, that’s worrisome. I’ve never seen her looking so happy at an event. I hope for her health’s sake that she starts to eat more.

  187. beautyqueen18 | 30/08/07

    Dramatic headline skinny girl. And I really don’t think she is scary skinny. I think she looks okay. Sure some weight wouldn’t hurt, but being this thin looks natural on her. Yeah, I think Kate Bosworth, Angelina Jolie, Angelina Jolie, and Posh are too thin. I think being skinny suits Keira because she doesn’t get those horrible chest bones jutting out. And she has a butt! The second picture is a little scary, but she looks great in the last two.

  188. beautyqueen18 | 30/08/07

    Sorry, I meant to type Amy Winehouse, instead of Angelina Jolie twice.

  189. beautyqueen18 | 30/08/07

    Sorry, I meant to type Amy Winehouse, instead of the Angelina Jolie twice.

  190. b | 30/08/07

    she doesn’t look 2 skinny. skinny yes, but not too. and im starting to think this is a natural weight for her. she’s been this way forever, and truly she doesnt look anorexic-just small. theres no bones popping out or anything.

  191. Maxx05 | 30/08/07

    I actually saw several more pictures from this photo shoot, and she looked to be her usual slim self, and fine. These particular shots catch her at angles that make her appear particularly diminutive. Her arms are not too thin, and her shoulders and head are proportional to the rest of her body, they just don’t appear to be so in these pics.

  192. pookie | 31/08/07

    she is SOOOOOOOO hot…day-ummm..i duno wat yall r talking bout…i think yall are just J-E-L-O-U-S… shes young, beautiful…tall, slim, sucessful….and ur all probably short, fat, old and ugly…:D… shes always been skinny…sum people are like that GET OVER IT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! thats life…sum ppl are just hotter then others, stop posting negative things about her cuz shes better than u…it wont make u any hotter…shes busy having a life, going out..dancing…partying… enjoying her youth..thats prolly y shes so skinny..shes not at home sitting down eating infront of the t.v like you losers… !!!

  193. Beck | 31/08/07

    she’s always had a boyish kind of body though. A slim athletic build and she’s taller than alot of the reali skinny stars around is she not ? Second picture she looks like a “funnybone” character if anyone remembers them. Kiera my dear you look better with short hair.

  194. ANONBLONDE | 31/08/07

    pookie…wooooow. So yeah you do realize that the likelihood of everyone posting here in the comments section being ’short’ ‘fat’ ‘old’ and ‘ugly’ is pretty much the most irrelevant and ridiculous claim ever, right? True, she’s always been very skinny but she just looks like a corpse in these pictures. There is nothing attractive about a girl with zero body fat, fine, downy hair covering the body (lanugo) and protruding bones that make you look like the crypt keeper. She is obviously using unhealthy means to maintain a below average and beyond healthy weight and while a lot of you may think she looks ‘fabulous’ now (which is quite disturbing and only further proves how fucked up and distorted our society’s vision on what is ‘healthy’ is…) she is going to pay for it in the future…it’s going to come back and hit her hard later on in her life…same for all of the other ’size zero stars’…

  195. Lora | 31/08/07

    She’s beautiful and she’s not anorexic at all!
    She’s slim and that’s all.it’s genetic.
    I’ve similar body type. I’m 5.5 and I’m 100lbs…
    And I eat when I’m hungry.Pasta and pizza too.

  196. elka | 31/08/07

    the truth is she has always been skinny
    fluctuated here and there but always skinny.

    i think the real crime here is her hair
    is that dark regrowth or some sort of streaks gone wrong. its hideous!

  197. SupermodelSuzie | 31/08/07

    She wouldn’t look so bad if she had a chest. I LOVE the dress!

  198. Lola | 31/08/07

    She looks great!
    I really believe her when she says that it’s just the way she’s built… I have a lot of friends who are just natural skinny girls. Like Keira is.
    I feel sorry for her cause she has to deal with constant anorexia accuses…

  199. Wilfi | 31/08/07

    She looks perfect! and she is not a skeleton!
    I love this very sexy Girl

    Regards
    Wilfi

  200. cokate | 31/08/07

    That’s not a skeleton, come on! she looks good. she has always been thin. Her upper body is small. if someday she decides to gain weight it will go to her legs and she will have thunder thighs and cankles. Don’t do it Keira!

  201. Lupe | 31/08/07

    Cameron Diaz Legs

  202. Sasha | 31/08/07

    LOL. Her face looks so big compared to the rest of her body. How the hell is it held up?

    Disfigured body!? I think so. She looks absolutely shitty, and a lot older than her 22 years old self.

    Her hair looks thin as well, which definitely indicates lack of proper nutrition.

    All of you stating that she’s small on top are right, but this doesn’t even look natural anymore.

  203. melloe | 31/08/07

    she’s probably smiling so sincerely because her anorexia is finally paying off

  204. Josie! | 31/08/07

    She is not that thin, she is just pare shaped. I have her same build, and my BMI is above 17.

  205. snow storm | 31/08/07

    God her arms and waist are tiny. o my god she has definitely lost weight. far far too much

  206. Poochie | 31/08/07

    She looks gorgeous! Sure she may be tiny, but shes always been like that. Regardless, she is very talented and has a great style.

  207. Minerva | 31/08/07

    Her face in that last pic reminds me of Drew Barrymore…

  208. causethisiswhyi'mhot | 31/08/07

    i would actually quite like to have her figure,sadly,it is not meant to be.

  209. Jeneroni | 31/08/07

    i love that shes thin on top and got a big booty :]
    she could be the british JLO?

  210. baybaygurl | 31/08/07

    She is so gorgeous,but she desperately needs to eat something!! And soon.

  211. sarque | 31/08/07

    I think she’s absolutely beautiful. She and I are built somewhat similarly though to be fair, she is probably 10 pounds or so slimmer, and it’s possible that this is just natural. She’s always been slim, and I think the dress makes her look skinnier than she is. She does not appear unhealthy, in any case.

  212. ~*bonez*~ | 31/08/07

    Whoa Pookie~ since you’re posting here, I quess you’re not hot either. Get over yourself.

    Keira looks awful~much too thin. And she HASN’T ALWAYS BEEN THIS SKINNY. Do a search and you will see she lost weight around the time of “Bend it Like Beckman” and hasn’t really changed much since. That means it isn’t “natural thinness.” She’s doing something to keep her weight on the verge of unhealhty.

  213. Sammietta | 1/09/07

    I use to think she was very beautiful but now I think shes disgusting. I just changed my mind. Ew.

  214. Sammietta | 1/09/07

    it looks like shes forcing a smile on her face. I think shes anorexic.

  215. Irene | 1/09/07

    she’s skinny, but she does look fine. not way too skinny, but she shouldn’t loose more weight..

  216. Barbie_Princess | 1/09/07

    @Jeneroni
    Big booty?! Are you kidding me?

  217. DAYANARA | 1/09/07

    I DONT KNOW WHY BUT I THINK SHE IS ONE OF THOSE FEW GIRLS THAT WE ALWAYS HATE THAT ARE NATURAL SKINNY, I HAVE A FRIEND THAT IS LIKE THAT AND HER BODY TYPE IS JUST LIKE KIERA´S . I SAW HER IN THAT MOVIE “BEND IT LIKE BECKHAM” AND SHE WAS VERY HEALTHY AND ATHLETIC, AND YET SHE WAS SKINNY SINCE THEN.
    IT SEEMS TO ME THAT MANY OF THESE PHOTOGRAPHS ARE PHOTOSHOPPED.

  218. takehold | 2/09/07

    OMG, I can’t help but think she looks amazing. And look at that smile! Gorgeous.

  219. sesshoku | 2/09/07

    Kiera looks good, the dress maybe makes her look a bit funny but with a tighter more clingy outfit shell look great showing off how petite and adorable she is.

  220. Oksana | 2/09/07

    I would not say she looks too thin she looks healthy and in a good shape to me, she doesnt look anorexic

  221. Keelia | 2/09/07

    To Pookie:
    jealous is “J-E-A-L-O-U-S”. Not “jelous”- its harder to take you seriously when you go to emphasise something and spell in wrong!! :D

  222. Sylvie | 3/09/07

    These photos almost look fake. Especially the one where she’s turned to the side. You can see her other elbow…it looks odd. I should just start copying and pasting my comments for all these skinny celebs. Once again, you weren’t that thin when you became a household name so why do it now????? It’s stupid!

  223. Rosalind | 3/09/07

    She is so thin, but very beautiful. How much do you think she weighs now? I am 5 foot 7 (like Keira) and currently weigh 116 pounds. I think she must be 100 or less. Its very tempting to think that by losing that extra stone and a bit, I could look as beautiful as her. I know thats not how it works though. Wow, this website is bad for bringing out one’s latent anorexia.

  224. oolaar | 3/09/07

    She looks exactly the same as she has done for what, a year now? Or even since she’s come into media attention.

    In Bend It Like Beckham she was skinny. She’s got a very thin upper body, yet more weight on her bum and thighs, which you can see when she’s turned to the side, this seems to be her natural body shape.

    If she’s lost any weight at all in this picture, I would bet it’s only one or two pounds. She hasn’t changed.

  225. sara | 3/09/07

    she looks gorjis and i have to agree with oolaar

  226. lea | 3/09/07

    i love her and she looks fine. she has a naturally slender upper body, and the colouring of the dress makes her look elongated. instead of bitching about her *anorexia* to make urselves feel better, y dont u just accept that some people are like this?

  227. El | 9/09/07

    She’s always been skinny. Her dress covers her hip area which is her widest part. Look at her arms - she’s no skeleton.

    I think she looks beautiful. Could stand to gain some, but honestly, leave this poor girl alone.

  228. aimee | 10/09/07

    it might be weird i would so love to have that body and i weight 58 kg with being 1.81 tall

  229. proanawanwan | 25/09/07

    I think that Kiera looks really nice, the dress is gorgeous.She looks really healthy and really pretty.Her body is perfecto!!!

  230. tiff | 26/12/07

    i really dont see why people are raising a fuss about kiera’s weight. i am 20 years old, 109 lbs and i have almost the exact same body shape as kiera- like my bones definitely are not sticking out anywhere but im not tubby. i have never been on a diet either. just calm down and back off a little! : ) some girls are just naturally petite.

  231. HEHE | 28/12/07

    GORGEOUS GORGEOUS GORGEOUS …she looks so perfect here…waw:P

  232. HEHE | 28/12/07

    like so young, and FRESH… having lots of fun …shes just so adorable

  233. Reenefupnob | 24/03/08

    I’d prefer reading in my native language, because my knowledge of your languange is no so well.

  234. September | 8/06/08

    Ew.

  235. Kaysa | 9/06/08

    I think she looks lovely! Yes, she is skinny, but still pretty all the same. OMG I wish I looked like her.

Share Your Thoughts